Is QFT Linear?
Yes — but with an important distinction:The field equations are often linear for free fields, but interacting QFT is not linear.
Let’s do a few concrete Weyl-vector examples.
1. Expand pμσμ
Useσμ=(I,σx,σy,σz)
and, with metric (+,−,−,−),pμ=(E,−px,−py,−pz)
Sopμσμ=EI−pxσx−pyσy−pzσz
Example: particle moving in the z-direction:pμ=(E,0,0,p)
Thenpμσμ=EI−pσz =(E−p00E+p)
Similarly,pμσˉμ=EI+pσz=(E+p00E−p)
2. Massless right-handed Weyl equation
For a massless right-handed spinor,pμσμψR=0
Using the z-direction result:(E−p00E+p)(ab)=0
For a massless particle,E=p
so(0002E)(ab)=0
This gives2Eb=0
sob=0
ThereforeψR=(10)
up to normalization.
This is spin-up along the direction of motion.
So a right-handed massless Weyl spinor has positive helicity:h=+21
3. Massless left-handed Weyl equation
For left-handed spinors,pμσˉμψL=0
Usingpμσˉμ=(E+p00E−p)
and E=p,(2E000)(ab)=0
This givesa=0
soψL=(01)
This is spin-down along the direction of motion.
So a left-handed massless Weyl spinor has negative helicity:h=−21
4. Massive Dirac case: left and right are coupled
The chiral Dirac equations arepμσμψR=mψL pμσˉμψL=mψR
Again take motion along z:pμσμ=(E−p00E+p) pμσˉμ=(E+p00E−p)
Suppose spin-up, so useψR=(A0),ψL=(B0)
Then the first equation gives(E−p)A=mB
The second gives(E+p)B=mA
From the second,B=E+pmA
UsingE2−p2=m2
we also haveE+pm=mE−p
SoψL=E+pmψR
For very high energy,E≫m
soE+pm≈2Em≪1
Therefore a high-energy spin-up massive fermion is mostly right-handed, with a small left-handed component.
That is why chirality and helicity become nearly the same at high energy.
Does This Mean QFT Is Linear Like QM?
Partly yes, but mostly no.
Free QFT is linear
The free Klein–Gordon equation is linear:(□+m2)ϕ=0
The free Dirac equation is linear:(iγμ∂μ−m)ψ=0
The free Weyl equation is linear:iσμ∂μψR=0
So for free particles, QFT resembles ordinary quantum mechanics: superpositions work cleanly.
But interacting QFT is generally nonlinear
Once interactions are included, the equations are no longer simple linear wave equations.
Example scalar interaction:L=21(∂ϕ)2−21m2ϕ2−4!λϕ4
The equation of motion becomes(□+m2)ϕ+3!λϕ3=0
That ϕ3 term makes it nonlinear.
QED is also interacting
For the electron field interacting with electromagnetism:(iγμDμ−m)ψ=0
whereDμ=∂μ+ieAμ
So the electron field couples to the photon field.
The Maxwell equation also gets a source term:∂μFμν=eψˉγνψ
That source contains products of fields.
So the full coupled theory is nonlinear.
The clean answer
Quantum states still evolve linearly in Hilbert space.
But:the field dynamics of interacting QFT is not linear in the fields.
So QFT keeps the linear superposition principle of quantum mechanics, but interactions make the field equations and scattering structure much richer.
Leave a Reply