Projection Operators and Gleason’s Theorem


Projection Operators and Gleason’s Theorem

1. Projection Operators in Quantum Mechanics

A projection operator \( P \) is a Hermitian operator satisfying:

\( P^2 = P \)

These operators represent quantum measurement outcomes. If a system is in state \( |\psi\rangle \), the probability of measuring an outcome associated with projection \( P \) is:

\( P_{\psi} = \langle \psi | P | \psi \rangle \)

2. Projection Operators in Observables

An observable \( A \) with discrete eigenvalues \( a_i \) can be expressed using projection operators \( P_i \):

\( A = \sum_i a_i P_i \)

The probability of measuring \( a_i \) is given by the Born rule:

\( P(a_i) = \langle \psi | P_i | \psi \rangle \)

3. Gleason’s Theorem

Gleason’s theorem states that in a Hilbert space of dimension \( d \geq 3 \), the only possible probability measure satisfying quantum additivity must be:

\( P(E) = \text{Tr}(\rho E) \)

where \( E \) is a projection operator and \( \rho \) is a density matrix.

4. Implications of Gleason’s Theorem

  • Justifies the Born Rule: Probability assignments must follow the standard quantum probability formula.
  • Rules out Non-Contextual Hidden Variables: If measurement outcomes are predetermined, the additivity assumption is violated.
  • Constrains Deterministic Quantum Theories: No assignment of definite values (0 or 1) to projection operators is consistent with quantum mechanics.

5. Connection to Bell’s Theorem

Gleason’s theorem disproves non-contextual hidden-variable theories but does not rule out contextual hidden-variable theories. Bell later extended this result with Bell’s inequalities, showing that hidden-variable theories must be nonlocal.

6. Conclusion

  • Projection operators define quantum measurement outcomes.
  • Gleason’s theorem proves that probability in quantum mechanics must follow the Born rule.
  • Hidden-variable theories that assume predetermined values contradict quantum probability rules.